By Lucy Komisar

Maybe it’s an effort to tap new audiences, but “The Unbelievers” by Nick Payne is the second play I’ve seen this week which is really an expanded melodramatic sitcom. It’s about the devastation wrought on a woman whose teenage son disappears. It lacks emotional power, partly because it doesn’t build inexorably to a climax. The play in effect takes place the first week, a year later and seven years later, with no scene changes, just characters walking off and on stage to indicate times shifts. And the times are repeatedly mixed so you don’t immediately know where you are or see how events developed.
The story take place in England, though there’s nothing especially British about it but the accents. Oscar disappeared one day coming home from school and all that was ever found was an empty wallet at a gas station. The mother, Miriam Wright (Lauren Ambrose) disintegrates to the point of screaming at a patron in a food market, hugging a visitor so brutally that she writhes in pain and seeking out a medium.

Police have done door to door investigations and searches and put the story on TV to attract leads, to no effect. The inspector (Marjan Neshat) says most kids who disappear are runaways. But there’s no indication Oscar was disturbed.
Miriam’s ex-husbands Karl Khoury (Hadi Tabbal) and David Wright (Tom Riley) and their children Nancy Khoury (played the night I attended by understudy India Shea) and Margaret Wright (Elizabeth Yeoman) want the family to move on, to get closure, and they organize a memorial. She wants to go to Ghent to track down one more lead.

An interesting element is that ex’s Karl and David look alike, same physique, both with Mamdani-style moustache and beard and short black hair. So that was her type. And she suggests to each in turn that they have sex.
I suppose “the unbelievers” is supposed to mean those who think Oscar is no longer alive. An ironic term for the rational members of the family.
The acting is fine, especially Ambrose as Miriam and Yeoman as her daughter Margaret. And director Knud Adams makes the characters real. But there’s nothing in Payne’s text that grabs you, that makes you feel sympathy for anyone in the drama. In the end, you don’t really care what happened to Oscar.
“The Unbelievers.” Written by Nick Payne, directed by Knud Adams. Manhattan Theatre Club, NY City Center Stage 1, 131 East 55th St, NYC. 1hr50min. Opened Nov 5, 2026, closes Nov 29, 2026.